May 13, 2008
The US Forever
I love America. I like western culture. I don’t ever want to be oppressed by people from another country. A long time ago I would have thought these thoughts and then moved on to playing a game or read a book. But unfortunately, now I am worried enough to shut down the Xbox360 and blog. Why? The future of the US, perhaps western civilization is in doubt. Each day our countries relative strength wanes while China (our biggest long term threat) grows. Within 10 years its economy will be larger than ours. In 50, with a per capita gdp in line with ours, its will be three times our size. Most people hear this and proceed to think at least the US won’t be bullying other countries anymore. I hear this and cry. I realize, unlike others who are too constrained by ideology to see what is blatantly clear, that other countries won’t be like us. They won’t be the glbes policemen trying to keep everyone safe from theirselves. No, They will try to conquer the world.
Before you call me crazy, let me remind you of what EVERY other country with power has done:
Islam
Russia – Communism, attempted to conquer the world by force and ideology. Succeeded in creating and empire known as the ‘Soviet Union’
Germany – Perhaps the cruelest country ever. Tried to create an empire known as the Third Reich
Japan – Empire of the Rising Sun
Britain – “The Sun Never Sets…”
France – Napolean, etc.
Spain – Conquistadors
Hapsburg Empire – …
Ottoman Empire
Moors
Mongels
Rome
Egypt
Etc.
The point is that every nation that has ever gained an upper hand has sallied forth to conquer except for one, us, the US. If we wanted to, we probably could have created an empire. But we didn’t. And now our strength is our weakness. We have forgotten what it is like to NOT be the strongest and are not sufficiently worried about our future. Fortunately 3 simple policy changes can dramatically alter the long-term outlook of our Nation. Unlike Britain, we do not need to fall into obscurity. We have one of the largest landmasses in the world, and perhaps the largest habitable land. We have the 3rd largest population. We have the highest Per Capita of any large country. So what can we do?
1 – Change our immigration policies. Immigrants may increase our population, but if we continue to let in 3rd world people we will become a 3rd world country. We should limit immigration to only the best and brightest from around the world. Australia has this policy, and so should we. Moreover, we need to limit the quantity of people wishing to become Americans. If Europeans are not the majority of people, the country will no longer be a European country.
2 – Make Americans American again. The rise of the hyphenated American means that people are identifying less and less as Americans, and more by their country of origin. It is fine if people are from different ethnic groups as long as they adopt American culture. There should be no black culture, no white culture, no Asian culture — there should be an American culture. We do not need to eliminate peoples heritage, but everyone in America should have a western mindset and ultimately be loyal to our country. To do this will take a great cultural shift away from multiculturalism.
3 – Increase the Total Fertility Rate. One of the great strengths of our nation is not just that there are already 300MM people here, and that many of them are well educated, but that our country is so big. America has one of the lowest population densities of any developed country. We have plenty of room for more people – If our population density were as high as China’s (which is lower than much of Europe) we too would have 1.3B people. That may be to crowded, but in truth population brings power. A TFR of ~2.5 would ensure slow and steady growth with a reasonable youthful population.To accomplish an increase fertility rate we would simply need to give a PERCENTAGE tax break for each child a couple has. This would encourage both the rich and poor to produce children, and would reduce dysgenic effects of a straight up subsidy.
We can do it.
This reads like the product of frustration rather than reasonable policy.
1) I understand what you are saying is that mass-importing grunt labor to artificially keep down labor costs is culturally irresponsible, but your “3rd world people” statement is too negatively distracting.
2) Sub-cultures tolerance can and does work. It’s the secret behind the wild success of the Hellenistic empire. The problem is that no one seems to be assuming responsibility for American culture. See 1). For that matter, watch television. When “American culture” is for sale to the highest bidder, expect people to respect it with likewise reverance.
3) The problem is that social success has an inversely related with reproductive success, not that there’s not enough people in America.
I bookmarked your blog, thanks for sharing this very interesting post
America did maintain an informal empire in the New World; during the Cold War we overthrew plenty of democratic governments (allende etc.) we didn’t like. Global capitalism can also be pretty nasty for third world countries. Sure we weren’t the most evil empire in the world…but that’s counting really nasty ones like the Mongols and the Nazis. Also, the Brits arguably left behind some good things like English, and ex-British colonies did better than ex-colonies of other nations. We didn’t mess around that much in the Old World because we have two oceans protecting us.
My argument for maintaining American hegemony as long as possible is simple: we are Americans, and it’s good to be to the king. Even a declining America would be safe for a while–it’s difficult to launch an overland invasion–but eventually China or Russia might feel safe making an agreement with Mexico.
I actually think immigration would be ok if the engines of assimilation were still working, and some selectivity were maintained. That said I’m more worried about restoring our country’s economic competitiveness through rebuilding our manufacturing base–it’ll give us money in the long run by giving us stuff to sell, and we have to be able to pump out tanks at the drop of a hat should it become necessary.